With the exception of the famous rooftop performance for the Let It Be film in '69, The Beatles stopped playing live pretty early in their career, in '66. Even before that, they struggled to be heard above the legions of screaming fans. Their small live legacy consists of some live-at-the-BBC-studio recordings, plus Live At The Hollywood Bowl and Live At The Star Club Hamburg - all displaying their early pop/rockabilly side. The relevant performances aren't bad, but nothing special either. Since the band broke up, John and Ringo have barely ever played any Beatles songs live, and George has stuck to his own compositions for the band. So it fell to Paul to keep the Lennon/McCartney songbook alive. Only, in this case the billing is reversed: instead of Lennon/McCartney, here the songwriting credit goes to McCartney/Lennon. According to Paul, he only reversed the credit on songs written by him (the songwriting team had agreed to share credit 50/50 regardless of each song's principal songwriter). For this specific live album, mostly culled from his 2002 US tour, two thirds of the setlist is comprised by Beatles songs. Which makes it probably the closest one can get to a true Beatles live album. Is this how they would sound like at the beginning of the 21st century? Who knows, really? Truth is, there are Beatles tribute bands out there which sound more than the original than Paul's band does. I can't tell if that's a good or a bad thing though. Would I prefer hearing Paul play with John, George, and Ringo impersonators? Honestly, probably yes. But that would have been a tribute band rather than Paul McCartney and his band. As it is, he doesn't get overly creative with the arrangements: songs either sound similar to the originals ("Hello, Goodbye", "All My Loving", "Fool On The Hill"), or starker ("We Can Work It Out", the ukulele version of George's "Something"). John's harmonies are notably absent at times. When harmonies are evident, as in "Getting Better" and "Hey Jude", they have a more soul/gospel feel. Then, of course, you have the classic McCartneyesque ballads ("Blackbird", "Yesterday", "Michelle") which were very stark and fragile to begin with. Somehow, these never sound great in a live setting. Orchestral arrangements on "Eleanor Rigby", "She's Leaving Home", and "The Long and Winding Road" are replicated; presumeably the orchestral parts are played on the synthesizer. Songs from Let It Be are among the best, with small differences adding to rather than subtracting from the song: some jazz piano on "The Long and Winding Road", sax on "Lady Madonna", an electric guitar solo on "Let It Be". The upbeat rockabilly-ish songs are loads of fun to listen to even if they don't deviate much from the originals ("Can't Buy Me Love", "Back in the U.S.S.R.", "I Saw Her Standing There"). The inclusion of a forgotten Beatles track ("Mother Nature's Son" from 1968's White Album) is a pleasant surprise. Three tracks taken from his then current solo LP Driving Rain ("Lonely Road", "Driving Rain", "Your Loving Flame") sound relatively weak among such company. Conversely, songs from 1973's Band On The Run ("Jet", "Let Me Roll It", "Band on the Run") still sound great. Other notable performances include the funky "Coming Up" (from McCartney II, 1980), "Maybe I'm Amazed" (from solo debut McCartney, 1970), and James Bond theme "Live and Let Die" (1973). There's also a poignant tribute to John Lennon composed shortly after his death ("Here Today" from Tug of War, 1982) while the CD closes majestically with "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band/The End". Back In The World is the international counterpart of 2002's Back In The US : it subtracts "C Moon" and "Freedom", replacing them with four tracks recorded in Mexico and Japan and uses a different performance of "Hey Jude", recorded in Mexico instead of New York. As a souvenir for Beatles fans, it's rather frustrating: on one hand, this is the closest one gets to listening to The Beatles live in the 21st century. On the other, it's disappointingly pedestrian. But who's to say that, had they stayed together and resumed performing, The Beatles would have been a great live band? Unfortunately, nothing except their crazy pre-fame Hamburg days points to that. Maybe it would have been better for McCartney to avoid comparisons altogether and stick to his solo stuff. But these songs deserve to be played live - and who's better equipped to do it than him?
**** for Hello Goodbye, Jet, Coming Up, Let Me Roll It, You Never Give Me Your Money/Carry That Weight, The Fool on the Hill, Eleanor Rigby, Here There and Everywhere, Michelle, Band on the Run, Back in the U.S.S.R., Maybe I'm Amazed, She's Leaving Home, Can't Buy Me Love, Live and Let Die, Let It Be, Hey Jude, The Long and Winding Road, Lady Madonna, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band/The End
*** for All My Loving, Getting Better, Lonely Road, Blackbird, Every Night, Mother Nature's Son, Here Today, Calico Skies, Let 'Em In, My Love, I Saw Her Standing There, Yesterday
** for Driving Rain, Your Loving Flame, We Can Work It Out, Something